The Value of Tax Loss Harvesting and Rebalancing During Volatility
- Joshua Rigden
- Apr 29
- 6 min read
Updated: Jun 25
In the world of investing, market volatility can be both a challenge and an opportunity. Two strategies that savvy investors use to navigate turbulent markets are tax loss harvesting and portfolio rebalancing. These techniques not only help manage risk but also have the potential to enhance returns and generate alpha—the excess return of an investment relative to a benchmark. This article explores the mechanics of these strategies, their benefits, and the improved returns they can produce.
What is Tax Loss Harvesting?
Tax loss harvesting involves selling securities that have declined in value to realize a capital loss, which can then be used to offset taxable capital gains or, in some cases, ordinary income. The proceeds from the sale are typically reinvested into a similar (but not identical) security to maintain the portfolio's asset allocation and market exposure, avoiding the IRS's wash-sale rule (which disallows losses if a substantially identical security is repurchased within 30 days).
Benefits of Tax Loss Harvesting
Tax Deferral: By offsetting capital gains with losses, investors reduce their current tax liability, effectively deferring taxes to the future. This deferral allows more capital to remain invested, compounding over time.
Increased After-Tax Returns: The tax savings from harvesting losses can be reinvested, potentially increasing the portfolio's long-term growth. Studies suggest that tax loss harvesting can add 0.5% to 1.5% annually to after-tax returns, depending on market conditions, tax rates, and the investor's ability to execute the strategy consistently.
Volatility as an Opportunity: Volatile markets create more opportunities to realize losses, as securities are more likely to dip below their cost basis. This makes tax loss harvesting particularly valuable during periods of market turbulence.
How It Generates Alpha
Tax loss harvesting generates after-tax alpha by improving the investor's net return without increasing market risk. The alpha comes from the tax savings, which act as a "return" that is independent of market performance. For example:
If an investor realizes $10,000 in losses and uses them to offset $10,000 in gains taxed at a 20% long-term capital gains rate, they save $2,000 in taxes.
Reinvesting this $2,000 allows it to grow, compounding the benefit over time.
The alpha is most pronounced for high-net-worth individuals in higher tax brackets, where the tax savings are larger.
What is Portfolio Rebalancing?
Portfolio rebalancing involves adjusting a portfolio's asset allocation back to its target weights after market movements cause it to drift. For example, if a portfolio is designed to be 60% stocks and 40% bonds, a stock market rally might push the allocation to 70% stocks and 30% bonds. Rebalancing would involve selling some stocks and buying bonds to restore the 60/40 mix.
Benefits of Rebalancing During Volatility
Risk Management: Rebalancing ensures that the portfolio remains aligned with the investor's risk tolerance and financial goals. During volatile periods, this discipline prevents the portfolio from becoming overly exposed to riskier assets.
Buy Low, Sell High: Rebalancing inherently follows a contrarian approach—selling assets that have performed well (and are potentially overvalued) and buying those that have underperformed (and may be undervalued). This can enhance returns over time.
Improved Returns: By systematically rebalancing, investors capture gains from outperforming assets and reinvest in underperforming ones, potentially boosting long-term returns. Historical studies indicate that rebalancing can add 0.2% to 0.5% annually to portfolio returns, depending on the frequency and market conditions.
How It Generates Alpha
Rebalancing generates alpha by exploiting market volatility to capture small, systematic gains. During volatile periods, asset prices fluctuate more, creating larger deviations from target allocations. Rebalancing allows investors to:
Sell assets at relative highs and buy at relative lows, capturing incremental returns.
Maintain a disciplined approach, avoiding emotional decisions driven by market swings.
The alpha from rebalancing is often referred to as the rebalancing premium, which arises from the mean-reverting nature of asset prices over time.
Combining Tax Loss Harvesting and Rebalancing
When used together, tax loss harvesting and rebalancing can amplify their benefits, particularly during volatile markets. Here's how they complement each other:
Synergistic Execution: Volatile markets often create both tax loss harvesting opportunities (due to price declines) and the need for rebalancing (due to allocation drift). For example, selling a stock to harvest a loss can also help rebalance the portfolio if that stock's allocation has grown too large.
Enhanced After-Tax Alpha: The tax savings from harvesting losses can be reinvested to facilitate rebalancing, further aligning the portfolio with its target allocation. This dual approach maximizes both tax efficiency and risk-adjusted returns.
Compounding Benefits: The combined effect of tax deferral and rebalancing can significantly boost long-term wealth. For instance, a portfolio that consistently harvests losses and rebalances during volatility may outperform a passive portfolio by 1% to 2% annually on an after-tax basis, assuming disciplined execution and favorable market conditions.
Quantifying the Impact
The exact alpha and improved returns from these strategies depend on several factors, including:
Market Volatility: Higher volatility increases opportunities for both tax loss harvesting and rebalancing.
Tax Rates: Investors in higher tax brackets benefit more from tax loss harvesting.
Portfolio Size: Larger portfolios with more securities offer more opportunities to harvest losses.
Frequency of Execution: Daily or weekly monitoring (common in automated platforms) can capture more opportunities than annual rebalancing or harvesting.
Empirical Evidence
Tax Loss Harvesting: Research from firms like Wealthfront and Betterment suggests that tax loss harvesting can add 0.5% to 1.5% annually to after-tax returns in volatile markets. For a $1 million portfolio, this could translate to $5,000–$15,000 in annual tax savings, which compounds over time.
Rebalancing: A study by Vanguard found that rebalancing a 60/40 portfolio annually or when allocations deviated by 5% added 0.35% annually to returns compared to a never-rebalanced portfolio (based on data from 1926–2018).
Combined Effect: A 2020 study by Parametric Portfolio Associates estimated that combining tax loss harvesting and rebalancing could boost after-tax returns by 1% to 2% annually for high-net-worth investors in volatile markets.
Practical Considerations
While these strategies are powerful, they come with considerations:
Transaction Costs: Frequent trading to harvest losses or rebalance can incur costs, though these are often minimal with low-cost ETFs or robo-advisors.
Complexity: Tax loss harvesting requires careful tracking to avoid wash-sale violations and ensure compliance with tax laws.
Market Timing Risk: Rebalancing too frequently in extreme volatility could lead to selling assets before a rebound, though systematic rebalancing mitigates this risk.
Automation: Robo-advisors and wealth management platforms increasingly offer automated tax loss harvesting and rebalancing, making these strategies accessible to retail investors.
Conclusion
Tax loss harvesting and rebalancing during volatility are disciplined, tax-efficient strategies that can significantly enhance after-tax returns and generate alpha. By capitalizing on market downturns to harvest losses and maintaining a consistent asset allocation, investors can turn volatility into an opportunity. While the exact benefits depend on individual circumstances, these strategies can collectively add 1% to 2% annually to after-tax returns, compounding into substantial wealth over time. For investors looking to optimize their portfolios, embracing these techniques—especially in turbulent markets—is a proven path to long-term success.
Rigden Capital Strategies was founded on a simple belief: financial advice should be personal, transparent, and centered around your goals—not built on generic models or product-driven sales. With decades of combined industry experience, we’ve developed a process grounded in three core values: value, integrity, and progress.
As a fee-only fiduciary, we provide personalized, goals-based wealth planning services designed to adapt with your life. Our services include investment management, retirement and tax planning, and estate coordination. We use a mix of active and passive strategies to help clients navigate market changes with clarity and confidence.
We believe in building real relationships and delivering clear, actionable strategies—focused on long-term planning and aligned with your objectives.
Your goals, our strategies. Together, let’s make your goals happen.
Disclosure: This content is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be interpreted as financial, legal, or tax advice. While we strive for accuracy, we do not guarantee the completeness or reliability of the information provided. Investment decisions should be based on individual circumstances, and we recommend consulting a qualified professional before implementing any financial, legal, or tax strategies. Past performance is not indicative of future results, and all investments carry risks, including potential loss of principal. No investment strategy can guarantee success or protect against loss in all market conditions. Investors should carefully consider their risk tolerance, investment objectives, and financial circumstances before making investment decisions. This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized financial, legal, or tax advice. Investment advisory services are only provided to clients of registered investment advisors under a written agreement. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Always consult with a qualified financial professional before making any decisions based on this content.